We see both in Southeast Alaska. The way I tell them apart is the Tufted Puffin has a funny hairdo, and the Horned Puffin has some cool eye makeup. This guy sure looks like a Tufted to me.
He did it again this year. On his birthday he caught a huge halibut in excess of 200 lbs! We let her go. A female halibut that size will lay millions of eggs. Not to worry...we had halibut for dinner.